Shooting Closeups – Closeup filters and positive diopter lenses

One of the options to shoot closeup is to add magnification in front of your existing lens.  There are lens attachments called closeup filters or positive diopter lenses.  They are all the same thing but some are better than others.

The typical positive diopter lens is sold as part of a kit and often comes with it’s own case.  Here’s an example of a set of B+W single element closeup lenses.

The kit shown here is a pretty normal item and usually sells for less than $100 for the whole kit.  These kits are almost always single element lenses.   Each lens is identified by a number which indicates it’s magnifying power.  A kit usually has +1 to +4.  The lenses can be stacked, that is more than one put on your primary lens at a time.

All of the single element lenses will have problems with spherical and chromatic abberations because different colors of light focus at different planes.  Better closeup lenses have two elements and are usually referred to as apochromats.  The two elements are used to correct the spherical and chromatic abberation and generally do so very well.

Because they have two elements, they are thicker and heavier.  It’s pretty obvious when you compare the two.  A single element lens is no thicker than a filter while the apochromats are twice as thick.  The two element lenses may be referred to as doublets by some.

Nikon used to make two element apochromat lenses which were designated 3T and 4T in 52mm sizes and 5T and 6T in 62mm sizes, etc. but, these are no longer in production.  Nikon also made single element and referred to them as No. 0, No. 1 and No. 2. The lower magnifications didn’t need as much correction as the higher.

Canon still makes the 250D and 500D in a number of filter sizes.  The 250D is designed for short lenses and the 500D for longer lenses.  There are other vendors of true apochromats as well

The magnification that you will get with these lenses is a function of the focal length of the primary lens.  It will be different between a 50mm and a 135mm for example.

Pros

  • These are relatively cheap and easy to use. 
  • Because they are stackable you can often get just the right magnificaton.
  • There isn’t much distortion of image quality at lower magnifications
  • There is little effect on the f-stop

Cons

  • You will lose infinity focus with the lens in place
  • The focus range can be small and may need multiple tries to get the right combo
  • At stronger magnifications, some chromatic and spherical abberation can occur

I don’t have any examples of the use of these lenses since I moved to digital.  I found them fine for occasional use but, my interest in closeup work led me to better options fairly quickly.  The set shown was purchased to allow some closeup work with a Mamiya 645 film camera.

Advertisements

About birds n' bugs

Retired, living in SW Florida and spending my time at nature photography in my local area. I volunteer with a couple of local organizations to help my adopted home town. Travelling is now by airplane and car instead of a sailboat but happy anyway.
This entry was posted in Camera Gear, Camera primers, Shooting closeups and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s